Wednesday, September 16, 2015

Annulment reform and the Kasper proposal

Back in the innocent days we had discussing Cardinal Kasper's proposals, the suggestion was that people be allowed to receive Holy Communion despite living in uncanonical situations. He said, in an interview, that he thought reform of the process of annulment wouldn't make a difference to all that many people. Instead, we had to take a different view of the new, adulterous, unions, which people who had left perfectly valid first marriages had contracted. (My post about it.) He said:

And the second is not a marriage in the same sense, but there are elements of it—the partners take care of one another, they are exclusively bound to one another, there is an intention of permanence, they care of children, they lead a life of prayer, and so on. It’s not the best situation. It’s the best possible situation. Realistically, we should respect such situations, as we do with Protestants. We recognize them as Christians. We pray with them.
Part of the motivation for this was, no doubt, a naive belief that the annulment process could only be twisted so far, but another, and perhaps a more powerful one, is the observation that many of the couples in illicit second unions do not want an annulment.

This may seem surprising, but it is true. I've encountered this attitude myself; here is Mgr Basil Loftus about it (criticising 'the often negative and harmful purported 'solution' of marriage nullity.'), and here is Cristina Odone (angered by 'the practice of annulment, where you could effectively buy the Church’s collusion in untying the marital knot.')

Juventutem Mass for Persecuted Christians 25 Sept with Fr Julian Large and Dr John Newton of ACN

IMG_1012

The series of Juventutem Masses, at 7:30pm on the last Friday of each month in St Mary Moorfields continues; these are always sung, usually with chant, and supported by the Latin Mass Society.

Once a quarter the LMS and the FIUV provide special sponsorship to make possible a polyphonic Mass, for the intention of persecuted Christians around the world. The next of these is taking place on Friday 25th September, and will be celebrated by the Provost of the London Oratory, Fr Julian Large.

Afterwards, Dr John Newton of Aid to the Church in Need will give a talk.

Mass will be accompanied by Matthew Schellhorn and his Cantus Magnus group.

The Mass and the talk are open to all; the 'social' afterwards is restricted to the age-group 16-35.

IMG_1020

Support the work of the LMS by becoming an 'Anniversary Supporter'.

Tuesday, September 15, 2015

Worries about the arguments for annulment reform

IMG_0418
The Blessing of the Bride
In my last post, I summarised the arguments of the canonist Edward Peters on problems raised by the reform of the annulment procedures by Pope Francis' motu proprio Mitis Iudex.

I want to base my own reflections around two mutually inconsistent attitudes which are the hallmark of all too many reforms carried out in the Church since Vatican II, which appear to be present in this reform as well. (I wrote this post before reading Rorate Caeli's translation of excerpts from an article by Msgr. Pio Vito Pinto, the leader of the commission which crafted this reform; the article confirms my observations.)

The first is an impatience with the traditional approach to whatever the issue might be. In this case, the traditional approach places the burden of proof on the side of the validity of a marriage, which has the result that gaining an annulment takes on the appearance of a hurdling race. A petitioner has to prove that the marriage was void; he or she has to seek out grounds, and then evidence for those grounds, and then do it all over again with a second tribunal.

Where the system has been corrupted, of course, these obstacles may not be difficult to overcome, but the procedure still consists of overcoming them one by one. Where it has not been corrupted, then it remains a very real possibility that a petition will be refused even when the marriage is truly invalid, simply because it could not be proved to be invalid: in exactly the same way that a guilty man may walk free from from a criminal court for lack of evidence. But in the case of annulments, it does not appear to be a matter of erring on the side of caution, in that way that not imprisoning people without sufficient evidence counts as erring on the side of caution, but of erring on the side of bloodyminded intransigence. A refused petition is in most cases today a refusal to allow a couple married (or soon to be married) outside the Church to return to (or remain in) good standing and receive the sacraments. Isn't the very possibility of refusing a petition to a person in a marriage which is in reality invalid a horrifying one? Should we not err on the side of the invalidity of the marriages in front of tribunals?

No, of course not. Because the final result desired by petitioners is not, in fact, a declaration of nullity, in almost every case, but a valid marriage - a new one, that is, with a new partner. To place the burden of proof on the side of invalidity is to place a doubt on every single marriage on the face of the earth, including the marriage the petitioner wants to contract as soon as the decree is granted. It is, to this extent, self-defeating.

Monday, September 14, 2015

Vespers of the Dead for the House of Stuart, Wednesday in London

King James II (of England) and VIII (of Scotland), in exile in France
with his family, in 1694.
From the Royal Stuart Society

By kind permission of the Right Reverend Keith Newton, Ordinary of the Ordinariate of our Lady of Walsingham,
and the Reverend Mark Elliott-Smith, Rector of the Church of our Lady of the Assumption and St Gregory, Warwick Street
and
under the patronage of His Grace the Duke of St Albans, the Governor-General of the Royal Stuart Society,
and
the Chairman, Lord Aylmer, and the Council of the Royal Stuart Society
Vespers of the Dead
will be sung at
6.30pm
on
Wednesday 16 September 2015
in the
Church of our Lady of the Assumption 
and St Gregory
at
Warwick Street, London W1B 5LZ
for the repose of the souls of
King James II and VII, King James III and VIII
and
the deceased members of the 
Royal House of Stuart
the day of death of King James II & VII of England, Scotland, Ireland and France (de jure)

Chant schola of Corpus Christi Maiden Lane
And of St Bede Clapham Park

[Nearest tube: PICCADILLY CIRCUS]



Support the work of the LMS by becoming an 'Anniversary Supporter'.

Marriage and annulment reform

Christ the Judge
The canonist Edward Peters has done a great service to the Church with his short series of posts on Pope Francis' reform of the annulment process, with the motu proprio Mitis Iudex.

First thoughts, including the abolition of second instance.

More thoughts, including worries about the effects of the reform.

Lengthy procedures in Argentina

More on the causing of unnecessary doubts about the validity of marriages

Unlike Roberto de Mattei, whose article on the subject can be seen on Rorate Caeli, Peters is not too worried about the abolition of the requirement of 'second instance'. Until now, declarations of nullity have had to be confirmed by another tribunal, which obviously adds to the time and expense of the process. The new rules make this unnecessary.

While I agree with de Mattei that the change is clearly moving things in the direction of taking less seriously the marriage bond, I can see Peters' point as well. Where the canonical procedure is weak, for whatever reason, adding another weak tribunal to the process may do little to help.

Peters identifies three aspects of the reform which really do worry him, and I urge readers to see what he says in detail. They are:

1. Making relevant to the way cases are heard, whether both spouses agree to seek an annulment. Why should it be relevant? The rule will encourage an attitude of conspiring between estranged spouses to get the desired result - or pressure by one on the other to agree, for the sake of a quick result.

2. The rag-bag list of reasons to allow an accelerated procedure, which includes issues related to grounds for nullity such as lack of discretion in making the vows, with issues utterly unrelated, such as 'brevity of marriage', and issues expressed in terribly vague terms. As Peters says, this is going to lead people to have doubts about the validity of their marriages who should not. ('Gosh, I was pregnant when we married; I'd be able to have a quickie annulment. Doesn't that mean there is something wrong with my marriage?')

3. The accelerated procedure itself, which can be undertaken by a bishop assisted by people without any training in Canon Law. Bishops may have the authority, by virtue of their office, to judge cases, but putting them personally in the hot seat without the support of experts is a recipe for disaster.

I want to devote another post to some reflections of my own on this topic.

Support the work of the LMS by becoming an 'Anniversary Supporter'.

Sunday, September 13, 2015

Sat 19th: LMS Pilgrimage to Brinkburn Priory, Northumbria

Saturday, 19th September 2013: Pilgrimage to Brinkburn Priory, Northumberland



High Mass at 12 noon.

The address is Brinkburn Priory, Longframlington, nr Morpeth NE65 8AR. 

The priory was once the home of Augustinian canons, who chose this idyllic riverside site in the midst of the beautiful countryside of Northumberland. The priory is situated between the towns of Morpeth & Rothbury.

The Priory Church was re-roofed in Victorian times, and it is possible to have Mass inside it.

Please make a note in your diary as this is a wonderful setting for the EF of the Mass and we are (usually) blessed with lovely sunshine.


Support the work of the LMS by becoming an 'Anniversary Supporter'.

Thursday, September 10, 2015

Pilgrimage to Glastonbury this Saturday


Reposted: don't miss the chance to visit this ancient holy place. More details here.

Glastonbury Abbey is where you'll find the Holy Thorn, planted by St Joseph of Arimathea, the grave of King Arthur, and the site of martyrdom of the last Abbot, Bl Richard Whiting. Not bad for one place!

This year the Pilgrimage Mass will take place in the ruins of the Abbey itself.

The LMS Pilgrimage to Glastonbury
 There will be a Sung Mass in the Extraordinary Form on
Saturday, 12th September 2015 at 11:00 am
in
The Lady Chapel in the Abbey Grounds, Glastonbury
followed by a Rosary Procession, Lunch and then Benediction at 2pm in Our Lady of Glastonbury Church
The Celebrant will be Fr Philip Thomas
The music will be provided by the Rupert Bevan Singers
All are welcome
Tea and coffee will be available afterwards in the Church Hall, please bring a packed lunch
Support the work of the LMS by becoming an 'Anniversary Supporter'.